Christianity: “Shooting ourselves in the foot for 2,000 Years!”

John the Baptist, speaking about Jesus, said: “I am filled with joy at his success. He must become greater and greater, and I must become less and less. He has come from above and is greater than anyone else. We are of the earth, and we speak of earthly things, but he has come from heaven and is greater than anyone else. He testifies about what he has seen and heard, but how few believe what he tells them!” – John 3:29-32

Rebekah and I use a variety of materials for our morning devotions, including Bible reading, books of meditations, and the prayers of historic leaders over the years.

One book we are currently following is called, “2000 Years of Prayer.” Friday morning we read a translation of the letter the Emperor Constantine wrote to summon church leaders to the Council of Nicea (325 CE).

Wow! Talk about a piece of history that illustrates how we have been plagued by the same issues for so long! The document is interesting, it is illuminating, it is embarrassing, it is damning, it is prescient.

First, a little background; then, the letter:

– the Emperor Constantine

Constantine the Great, whose mother was a Christian, consolidated his power at the Battle of the Milvian Bridge (312 CE). From then on he was tolerant of Christianity and hoped that the worship of One God would unite his empire. When he discovered that Christians do not always agree he called the bishops together for the Council of Nicea.

What’s interesting to is how Constantine looks in from the outside and sees clearly how consistently Christianity shoots itself in the foot!

First, here are a few key quotes:

  • “Many of you have become so inflamed with the spirit of enmity and hatred that you have forgotten your own salvation…”
  • “Your Savior teaches you to practice unity and concord; but you have become masters of disunity and discord.”
  • “In this way you bring disgrace on yourselves and on your most holy religion…”

Constantine’s “invitation” to the 325 council at Nicea

– Council at Nicea (325 CE)

I continue to receive numerous letters from Christian leaders in every region. It is clear to me that many of you have become so inflamed with the spirit of enmity and hatred that you have forgotten your own salvation. Local synods are convened to resolve disagreements and disputes, but in some cases fail to reach any conclusion; in other cases the agreements are ignored and flouted. Your Savior teaches you to practice unity and concord; but you have become masters of disunity and discord. In this way you bring disgrace on yourselves and on your most holy religion. I therefore believe that under God I have a duty to impose unity on the church, using the imperial power which God has vested in me to put an end to all disputes. For this purpose I am convening a synod to which all Christian leaders will come. I will preside at this synod, listening to the beliefs and opinions of anyone who wishes to speak. I will weigh up what I have heard, and issue my judgment. I accept this task with reluctance; I have not sought it, but your misbehavior has forced it upon me. May the divine power of the great God keep you all in good health, both in spirit and in body, for many years. – Constantine the Great (325 CE)

The result – the Nicean Creed – is an extremely helpful document, especially how it affirms balance and unity within the Trinity. The creed lays out foundational Christian ideas that are clear and concise.

But Constantine’s motivation was to use God – and people’s faith – to unite and control his empire. “Using” faith to consolidate personal power is a trap many leaders still fall into today. But Christ turns the equation around, calling each one of us to be directed and used by God.

– Battle of the Milvian Bridge (312 CE)

At this challenging moment in our nation’s history, let’s not make that critical mistake. Constantine may have had some keen insights about the church, but his bottom line was to use faith as a tool to advance his own power.

Instead, our proper relationship to Jesus must be that of John the Baptist: “He must become greater and greater, and I must become less and less…” DEREK

4 comments

    • Hmmm. I may be wrong or it may just be the way everything is amplified by social media, but in the fifty-plus years I have been paying attention I’m not sure I have ever noted this level of angst and hostility and bitterness in the “public conversation.” Plus, as a fairly well-informed and mostly objective observer, I always see challenge come with commensurate opportunity – so I have hope too. Guess we will see how it all plays out.
      BTW I don’t recognize your handle, Sam, so we may not have communicated previously…?

  1. Oh my, your history lesson tied up some loose ends, I was just praying with this verse from Ephesians, “But now in Christ Jesus you who once were far away have been brought near by the blood of Christ. For he himself is our peace, who has made the two groups one and has destroyed the barrier, the dividing wall of hostility, by setting aside in his flesh the law with its commands and regulations.”
    I noticed the word “still” in your sentence, “’Using’ faith to consolidate personal power is a trap many leaders still fall into today.” Thank you for the reminder to be used by God.

    • Thanks so much, Cheryl. I love the Ephesians passage you referenced, “For he himself is our peace…” In my writing I always try to call ourselves to account – while at the same time keeping everyone engaged in the conversation. What a tremendous opportunity we have to be salt and light today, and to tell the truth about the good news by our love.
      Peace – Derek

Leave a Reply