When Information Surplus can lead to Knowledge Deficit

– set of encyclopedias

Don’t be conformed to the patterns of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your minds so that you can figure out what God’s will is—what is good and pleasing and mature.

Because of the grace that God gave me, I can say to each one of you: don’t think of yourself more highly than you ought to think. Instead, be reasonable since God has measured out a portion of faith to each one of you. – Romans 12:2-3

– my Facebook page

I understand that this post is going to be a little meta (not “Meta” the technology enterprise, but “meta” meaning self-referential) – a blog post about social media. But then I guess it really is “Meta” because it’s also partially about Facebook.

Anyhow, I have been thinking about social media and Facebook in particular because, other than this WordPress site Facebook is my primary platform (I have Instagram and Bluesky and X and Pinterest and LinkedIn but I don’t do much more than post links to this blog).

I remember back in the early 80’s our young adult Sunday school class had a lot of conversation around John Naisbitt’s book “Megatrends”. I haven’t read it since then but I remember a lot of emphasis on, interest in and wondering about the coming “Information Age.”

Most of us grew up – if we were lucky – with a set of Encyclopedias (Britannica) on the shelves and a library card in our wallet. In Rebekah’s house, family conversations, debates and arguments were often settled with the words “look it up!”

Rebekah and I purchased our first family computer (Apple lle) when Andrew and Naomi were five and three but even then, and adding our first CD-ROM encyclopedia around 1990, we could not begin to imagine just how much information would be at our fingertips 30-40 years down the road.

What we also could not imagine is how much of this newfound information would be useless (at best), patently false and dangerously deceptive. I believe people would be better off with just a boxed set of reliable up-to-date encyclopedias than unlimited access to all the reliable material in the world if it is diluted and lost in a sea of misinformation.

Too many people lack the tools (or – more importantly – the will) necessary to research and discern, and I see this demonstrated clearly on platforms such as Facebook and X and every day.

I find it hugely ironic and even more disturbing that the most significant megatrend I can identify today moves quickly beyond information and into ignorance.

Information surplus – knowledge deficit:

– information does not equal knowledge

We all understand the problem with “food deserts” (communities where it is next to impossible for people – especially low-income – to access food that offers balanced nutritional value). Available food in these places is over-processed, proven to compromise long-term health, high in sugar content and intentionally addictive.

In the same way I believe here in the United States we are in danger of becoming a knowledge desert, where too much of the available information is over-processed, deceptively packaged and intentionally addictive to the extent that it is intellectual junk-food.

I believe here in the United States we are in danger of becoming a knowledge desert, where too much of the available information is over-processed, deceptively packaged and intentionally addictive to the extent that it is intellectual junk-food.

As a content-provider with a fairly large audience, I want to encourage all of us to be more intentionally discerning when it comes to what we expose ourselves to – and what we swallow….

Remember that old public service commercial with the egg and the frying pan? “This is your brain… this is your brain on drugs…” I believe the image is apropos to this conversation – only this time the brain gets scrambled before it is cooked!

– working on content

“Food” for thought. How are we loading up our grocery cart of ideas?

Personally, I recommend the context of prayer and then making good use of the brains God issued us with – it is an egregious sin not to use them – DEREK

2 comments

  1. I could not agree more! There is so much obfuscation, miss-leading information, out right lies and the ommission of important information that the news media credibility has sunk to a low of around 35%. Facebook posts are creating animosity among friends and family in addition to inspiring violent actions. Anyone who is not closely examining all communication sources is guilty of “selective ignorance”.

    • Hi, Harold!
      Always good to hear from you. Even better when you use great words such as obfuscation! One of my favorite t-shirts reads “Eschew obfuscation.” No explanation necessary!
      Peace to you and yours

Leave a Reply